Thanks all for your thoughts on my father.
frogman as I have listened to Timmons' Moanin' hundreds of times being a big Art Blakey fan naturally I compared it to Mingus' rendition which I have had the "Blues And Roots" album for 10 years or more now but have listened to Timmons' Moanin' 10x as much, being, as orpheus10 said, the one true Moanin'.
And yes, I tried many times when I did listen to the Mingus Moanin', to see if I heard any similarities in the notes and melody. Of course I could not find any and so "assumed" , not having any scholarly musical background, that maybe it was the same song played at an up tempo (there are many jazz tunes in which this is true). Anyway I'm happy I now know for a certainty that they are not the same song.
Maybe someone can post the sheet music on the 2 songs (just the opening pages) so I can see what is obvious to those in the music field.
frogman as I have listened to Timmons' Moanin' hundreds of times being a big Art Blakey fan naturally I compared it to Mingus' rendition which I have had the "Blues And Roots" album for 10 years or more now but have listened to Timmons' Moanin' 10x as much, being, as orpheus10 said, the one true Moanin'.
And yes, I tried many times when I did listen to the Mingus Moanin', to see if I heard any similarities in the notes and melody. Of course I could not find any and so "assumed" , not having any scholarly musical background, that maybe it was the same song played at an up tempo (there are many jazz tunes in which this is true). Anyway I'm happy I now know for a certainty that they are not the same song.
Maybe someone can post the sheet music on the 2 songs (just the opening pages) so I can see what is obvious to those in the music field.