Most of the early Polk speakers used a passive woofer. This design extends the bass response and you don't have to worry about port chuffing.
The only negative I can think of is that the speaker needs to be airtight. If someone messed with the gaskets or was sloppy putting the speaker back together it will effect the bass. You can easily test for this by gently pushing in on the passive and hold it in. The drivers should move out and take a few seconds (the longer the better) to return to normal. If they push out but immediately start to go back in you have a leak somewhere.
The only negative I can think of is that the speaker needs to be airtight. If someone messed with the gaskets or was sloppy putting the speaker back together it will effect the bass. You can easily test for this by gently pushing in on the passive and hold it in. The drivers should move out and take a few seconds (the longer the better) to return to normal. If they push out but immediately start to go back in you have a leak somewhere.