Best Tchaikovsky’s 6th Symphony Recording

Curentzis isn’t entertaining, like that flashy woman you meet a bar, but would be hard to take as a regular partner.  I enjoyed the Kiril Petrenko who really takes a bit of a conservative view, but again I’ll state a preference for Bychkov in terms of striking the right balance between excitement without feeling like it is going to become unhinged.  These 3 recordings seemed to arrive at the same time so I tend to compare them

Curentzis isn’t entertaining, like that flashy woman you meet a bar, but would be hard to take as a regular partner.  I enjoyed the Kiril Petrenko who really takes a bit of a conservative view, but again I’ll state a preference for Bychkov in terms of striking the right balance between excitement without feeling like it is going to become unhinged.  These 3 recordings seemed to arrive at the same time so I tend to compare them

Curentzis-- ditto what mahler123 said.  It is more of an audiophile showpiece than an insightful piece of art.  A pretty woman with no depth.  

Like others, Mravinsky's performance is the one I go back to most often. I was a bit surprised at the comments about poor recording quality, but I've never heard their digital transfers. I have the original 1960's individual lp releases of 4,5,& 6 and the 1974 box set of 3 lps. The individual original releases of each symphony are some of the best DG recordings from that era IMO. The boxed set's lp's are not quite as good, but still quite decent. They aren't audio show dogs though. 

@photon46, I wrote that the recording is 'somewhat crude', based on the original 'alle hersteller' vinyl pressing. That's not the same as 'poor', just not the most refined. I certainly didn't mean it as a disclaimer. These recordings have lots of dynamics, more than most DGG's (from any vintage). As said, the performances are unequalled.