Categories:
Units: APL 3910 DV-50 ModWright 9000
Soundstage - 4 4 4
Rhythm & Pace 4 5 5
Depth of Image 5 4 4
Bass 5 5 4
Midrange 4 4 5
Treble 4 4 4
Musicality 4 4 5
Dynamics 4 4 4
Bloom 4 4 4
Inner Detail 5 4 4
Vocals 4 4 5
===================================================
47 46 48
===================================================
Some of the numbers are relative in that it would have been more accurate to award .5's to a specific player in certain categories.
In that case, the totals might change a bit, but the order would not. I had a clear preference in my own mind for #1, #2, and #3.
Of all the categories, I had some trouble with "bloom," which I decided to treat more like "palpability." Maybe that is what Bon intended, or maybe not.
Fives were awarded when something jumped out at me as being especially noteworthy (in a good way). So when you see all three players receiving fours, that's my way of noting in some cases that all three performed very well in that category and I could not distinguish a clear leader or laggard.
- Eric
Units: APL 3910 DV-50 ModWright 9000
Soundstage - 4 4 4
Rhythm & Pace 4 5 5
Depth of Image 5 4 4
Bass 5 5 4
Midrange 4 4 5
Treble 4 4 4
Musicality 4 4 5
Dynamics 4 4 4
Bloom 4 4 4
Inner Detail 5 4 4
Vocals 4 4 5
===================================================
47 46 48
===================================================
Some of the numbers are relative in that it would have been more accurate to award .5's to a specific player in certain categories.
In that case, the totals might change a bit, but the order would not. I had a clear preference in my own mind for #1, #2, and #3.
Of all the categories, I had some trouble with "bloom," which I decided to treat more like "palpability." Maybe that is what Bon intended, or maybe not.
Fives were awarded when something jumped out at me as being especially noteworthy (in a good way). So when you see all three players receiving fours, that's my way of noting in some cases that all three performed very well in that category and I could not distinguish a clear leader or laggard.
- Eric