I've had tube preamps that were too noisy for my system's downstream gain structure (both rush noise and microphonic feedback), and no amount of super special tube selection or tube dampers or HRS damper plates or expensive isolation stands did jack about it. Certainly, once you get "Platinum" selected tubes from Upscale Audio, there's not much (if any) improvement to be had from better selection.
You have to pick a preamp with reasonable gain for your system and good signal to noise ratio. This is one measurement you can glean from Stereophile reviews that actually matters - for example, see the ARC Reference 6's 100dB signal/noise, which is excellent for a tube pre, and tests in my difficult system bear this out.
BTW if your line stage uses 12AX7 and EF86s, those are NOT typical choices for a modern tube line stage. 6SN7, 6922, 6H30 seem to be preferred (also in my experience). Though with the old 6SN7GT types, it is HARD to find quiet examples today.