@kenjit
I wouldn't mind spending time with you discussing speaker design at some point. Many of your arguments are valid, but if a manufacturer decided to build a no compromise cabinet, very few could afford it. I am grateful for plywood and mdf. They allow me to build high quality cabinets that are affordable. I have been very strongly contemplating going into manufacturing again. I've been out of it for 35 years. Just recently I've experimented with light weight concrete composites. Vermiculite and styrene beads. In the end, I have abandoned this idea. In fact, I have been working with lighter wood products and using extensive bracing and deadening technics to built a very lightweight, strong and inert box. It may not be as inert as I would like, but I've done a few lightweight boxes that have produced very satisfying bass that can be handled much easier by an old geaser like me than your typical box..... It has been said all over. Construction time, Construction cost, Parts cost, time involved.... everything is a factor. In the end, The purchaser has to pay and the manufacturers are constantly juggling that cost vs selling price. It isn't that a better cabinet can't be made or anyone wants to deny you. I would suggest that you may fund a manufacturers development cost and I'm sure that you could get any type cabinet built that your hearts desire. Of course that isn't practical.... and practical is what this is all about. Good Listening, Tim (timlub)
I wouldn't mind spending time with you discussing speaker design at some point. Many of your arguments are valid, but if a manufacturer decided to build a no compromise cabinet, very few could afford it. I am grateful for plywood and mdf. They allow me to build high quality cabinets that are affordable. I have been very strongly contemplating going into manufacturing again. I've been out of it for 35 years. Just recently I've experimented with light weight concrete composites. Vermiculite and styrene beads. In the end, I have abandoned this idea. In fact, I have been working with lighter wood products and using extensive bracing and deadening technics to built a very lightweight, strong and inert box. It may not be as inert as I would like, but I've done a few lightweight boxes that have produced very satisfying bass that can be handled much easier by an old geaser like me than your typical box..... It has been said all over. Construction time, Construction cost, Parts cost, time involved.... everything is a factor. In the end, The purchaser has to pay and the manufacturers are constantly juggling that cost vs selling price. It isn't that a better cabinet can't be made or anyone wants to deny you. I would suggest that you may fund a manufacturers development cost and I'm sure that you could get any type cabinet built that your hearts desire. Of course that isn't practical.... and practical is what this is all about. Good Listening, Tim (timlub)