Which turntable should I choose?

Thank you three easy. I appreciate your comments. 

I have a Hanna SL. It is awesome for the price. Good choice. I also have a Thorens TD165 I've own from new MANY years. Thorens is a very good turntable but I also own a Feickert Volare turntable and have sampled other modern turntables. I found the modern turntables outperformed my TD165 pretty handily. But, my Thorens hasn't been professionally upgraded either. I've done many things to keep it in great shape to the point that I'm not sure how much additional work would help it to start with. I also have a Whest two.2 phono pre. That made a significant difference in the system with any TT/Cart combination. Don't discount the importance of the Pre. I also have a very well performing digital path. I enjoy my TT very much, but you have better/worse digital executions and analog executions. But rarely does the analog path sound better than digital path to me. My wife, who also grew up with records now simply refuses to listen to them vs my digital path. She has certifiable bat ears. Her hearing tests are off the charts. So I trust her analysis too. But ALWAYS go with what keeps you in the room listening to the music. That's all that counts! 

Thank you @bullitt5094

In the September 2020 isssue of the Absolute Sound a strong endorsement is made for the Technics 1500C, which at $1199 seems to fit the bill for you nicely.  I believe any Technics TT is worth consideration.  Thorens makes good TTs and I have owned a couple over the years, but must say that in my experience the Technics products (and in fact Japanese TTs in general) have proven to be more satisfactory. 

With respect, I believe you should carefully reconsider your cartridge choice.  From your description of the problem you had with the 2M Black it likely has at root the Shibata stylus.  The Shibata is fussy about set up and the condition of record grooves.  If all is not perfection itself, Shibatas are prone to be noisy.  I use Shibata on mint condition records, older records and especially mono records are often better served with an elliptical stylus.  If your new TT has a tonearm with removable head shell it would facilitate having more than one cartridge.  Were I you I would probably buy an elliptical stylus mounted on an aluminum cantilever type cartridge.  There are several good brands.

Believe me, sometimes less is more.  I have two TTs side by side, one is a $15K item fitted with an $8K cartridge (stereo) and stepped up through an almost $6K SUT.  Next to it is a $4K TT with an $8oo cartridge (mono) connected directly to the built in SUT in my phono stage.  Depending on the record it is very possible for the less expensive rig to sound better than the more expensive rig.  My point in telling you this is to advise you not to get hung up by labels or what other people are using or claiming is "the best" whatever that is supposed to mean.  When you are playing a record, what matters is how well your needs are served.  It is really all about the music.
Regards,
Bill

Technics GR. Start saving for a better phono amp.
The Ortofon Black is unforgiving with noise on records. e.g. Audio Technica VM750SH is not. A crappy arm and table doesn't help either.
Why are you looking at vinyl if you have issues with it and with comparing it to digital?