I'm with mofi here.
It will not get a repeat play.
It will not get a repeat play.
Tea For The Tillerman2
phcollie
"Very strange time trip going on in my head right now. Proves the point, old guys can still kill it. Fact " I agree with this sentiment. I doubt if many, or any, would like this album better than the original. Especially for those of us who loved the original in real time. I find it interesting to listen to these "old guys" so many years later. I think my favorite survivor is Peter Frampton on his Acoustic Classics album. I think he demonstrates a lot of matured sound through his voice and playing. Cat/Yosuf still has it too. |
What's not to like here? Wonderful songs, fantastic singer, beautiful arrangements, new life, I'm all in! Dylan on his last tour re-imagined Girl From The North Country (as he does nearly every show with nearly every song), and it was magical. Sad Lisa on this new disc, well, its a highlight for me. I saw the Cat's Attic tour in Philly a few years back, he went to a piano on the right corner of the stage and played/sang this (Sad Lisa), just him, was pure magic! I love this new recording of these old and wonderful songs. I do. |
Perhaps my comparisons implied a better/worse intent instead of the differences. I have to believe that this new edition is different for reasons that are meaningful to the Artist. Case in point, I can hear more of a haunting element in his voice in Sad Lisa that must result from 50 years of life experience and struggle that is part of the human condition. Disregarding the better or not opinion(s), I must respect that he has his reasons. |