I wouldn’t say that discernment is bad, but fixating on every imperfection is certainly not good. When I appreciate a fantastic Mahler recording by Bernstein or Solti or Boulez, and notice the small details that turn those recordings from being good into being some of the all-time greats, I am using discernment.
To use an analogy, a person wanting to learn to play an instrument initially doesn’t know that they sound bad. A good teacher would explain to them how they can improve, but it a helpful way. Then the student notices their mistakes, learns to correct them, and is ultimately happier than they were at first.
To use an analogy, a person wanting to learn to play an instrument initially doesn’t know that they sound bad. A good teacher would explain to them how they can improve, but it a helpful way. Then the student notices their mistakes, learns to correct them, and is ultimately happier than they were at first.