Marantz SA-1 holding up well agains next gen.?


How do people feel the Marantz SA-1 is holding up against some of the newer SACD and redbook players? I am particularly interested in comparison with the SA-11s1. Thanks.

--will
wrtickle
Lkdog,

I understand your concern about being badgered offline. I was amazed recently that on the same day I posted a review of a product that I just had modified by a reputable mod shop (over 600 modified units in the last year), I received an email from a person affiliated with another mod vendor (who will remain nameless, but he knows who he is - *wink* *wink*) that disparaged the work of the mod shop I chose.

Considering I was sharing with others my thoughts on a product which I have spoken highly of in stock form, let alone the modded version, I found this behavior to be a bit reprehensible and an invasion of my privacy.

I think shops like APL, Modwright, Empirical, TRL and others offer us options which we would never get from the OEM vendor. It's all good in my opinion and allows us to have a product that is suited to our sound preferences. There seems to be a mutual respect among these shops as well, which further confuses me as to why one particular person affiliated with a mod shop would find it necessary to disparage the work of others.
Clio09: You wrote ...

"I received an email from a person affiliated with another mod vendor (who will remain nameless, but he knows who he is - *wink* *wink*) that disparaged the work of the mod shop I chose."

Same here. I have recieved an e-mail like yours in my past from a mod vendor. I was shocked to have anyone e-mail me direct with negative comments about my choice ... (then again, my choice happened to be his competitor).

Regardless, this is strange behavior to say the least. I am willing to put the bad experience behind me.

"Can't we all just get along?" Rodney King.

Season's Greetings to all!

Jack
Merry Xmas to all.

Just got some nice new SACD's from Santa Claus:

Cannonball/Bill Evans- Know what I Mean
Art Pepper + Eleven Modern Jazz Classics
Cal Tjader/Stan Getz Sextet

Hi Rez lives.
Whew! I'm glad that we have that all behind us.

And don't worry guys, my wonderful Wife gave me a large print St. James Bible for Christmas. :)

So, besides doing a little reading, I've been enjoying my music, hearing things I haven't heard before.

Wishing all of you a prosperous New Year,

Jack Seaton