In practical ways, Duke's own method is not very different than my own.
I think duke is more conscious of the fact that most of us can't really place subs wherever we want to, which is true.
So, the reality is you place subs were best you can, but what happens next? You have to set up the crossover frequency and phase, and there's just no way to do both at once, and as Duke points out, having different phase or, by extrapolation, different low pass points and levels may be needed.
So, I think we are all circling the same tree trying to catch the same solution.