I think the SB halftime shows fall victim to the same problem the game itself does: very high expectations. After all the build-up, people want to be wowed with something good they haven’t seen, and in real life that is hard to do. In a regular concert venue, I’m sure the Weeknd’s performance would have been a big hit, but at halftime of the Super Bowl, it is easy to feel let down.
Also, the SB strives to appeal to a broad audience; something concert’s don’t necessarily have to do. You feature a vintage act, you mostly get older folks; you feature the latest young sensation, it will mostly be a young crowd. Trying to please various groups often falls short. I think Gaga and Bruno Mars both put on good shows, but normally the acts fall short . . like the game itself.
Also, the SB strives to appeal to a broad audience; something concert’s don’t necessarily have to do. You feature a vintage act, you mostly get older folks; you feature the latest young sensation, it will mostly be a young crowd. Trying to please various groups often falls short. I think Gaga and Bruno Mars both put on good shows, but normally the acts fall short . . like the game itself.