You might want to consider the Aesthetix Pallene with it's internal phono card. TAS just reviewed the phono card in the Aesthetix Mimas integrated amp and gave it a great review. The Pallene is their new preamp that is essentially the preamp section of the Mimas. I believe the retail cost with the phono card is $5,250. Over your budget I know but you may be able to get a discount from a dealer. If you are on the east coast you should talk to John Rutan at the Audio Connection in Verona, NJ. John can answer any questions about this preamp and I know he has sold quite a few of them already.
BTW, Aesthetix has not added the Pallene to their website yet but it looks exactly like the Mimas. Good Luck!