2. speakers
  3. 164704-13055

Spendor D9.2 vs. Harbeth super hl5 plus xd + REL Stentor III vs. Spendor Classic 100?

I am thinking of purchasing one of the following:

1). Harbeth SHL5 plus XD + REL Stentor III Reference Subwoofer due to lack of bass and low octave in bass.

2). Spendor Classic 100 - The bass is a bit noticeable and aggressive. 

3). Spendor D9.2.

My living room where the system will stand is: 5.5 meters x 8 meters, a standard ceiling of 2.7 meters and the entire construction is a 20 cm block. From the living room comes a 25 meters kitchen. The speakers I choose can stand up to about 1 meter from the front wall.

Anyone who has heard of at least 2 of them or a previous generation and can have an opinion on a comparison between them?

Thank you very much for your help.


128x128tomer_tsin
tomer_tsin's avatar
tomer_tsin OP
67 posts
 
Hello Normans,

thank you very much for the quick answer.

Regarding the Herbets speakers...I had a Rel Stantor III 20 years ago and it was excellent. As mentioned, I'm not a "bass head" type, a little extra bass is enough for me.

The Rel Stentor III offered to me is externally and internally 10/10 and an opportunity financially. In the past, Rel was considered very good musically, today a little less, what do you think?

I accept the fact that the Spendor Classic 100 needs real estate / air to breathe, do not know if 1 meter will suffice?
Not sure it will fit properly in my living room and a little skeptical about it.
tomer_tsin's avatar
tomer_tsin OP
67 posts
 
Hello keren 0006,

Thank you so much for your long, reasoned and instructive answer.

Tomer
noromance's avatar
noromance
9,877 posts
 
What krens0006 said above. The D7 or 9.2 would likely be all you’d need if you like a lot of detail. The Harbeth and Spender 100 a little less "aggressive."
Hold off on the subs (you need 2!) until you get the speakers. See how you feel then.


jjss49's avatar
Ag insider logo xs@2x
jjss49
6,612 posts
 
op

it would be helpful if you discuss what type of music you listen to and what you value most in terms of sonic characteristics of a high end hifi system

...and also if there is any ancillary equipment you intend to use, specifically, amplifiers
prof
3,478 posts
 

I don't really see the Spendor D series sitting comfortably with the Harbeth or Classic Spendor speakers.   The D series floor standing speakers are, to my ears, "Spendors" in name only: otherwise they are simply modern speakers and sound like it.  I don't find any particular continuity from their classic sound, no particular "Spendor magic" in the mids that sounds like Spendor.    Which doesn't mean someone can't like their mids of course...they just aren't the same.

The Harbeth and classic Spendors have at least something in common - that rich midband and classic box tuning which seems to give vocals in particular an organic presence, weight and roundness.

I owned the Harbeth SuperHL5 plus, and still own a little pair of Spendor S3/5s and even those share that similar trait.   I've been eager to hear the newer Spendor classic speakers but they are rare as hens teeth for audition.

More to discover