Those are two completely different sounding speakers. Only you can determine which of those speaker's sound you prefer. (Both are fine speakers.)
However, if your room is already too bright sounding, using the Sophia II's might be slightly more problematic, (as I thought their treble response was a bit more extended than the Amati's); although room treatments can fairly easily tame brightness. (Assuming you can implement them; I've found that the WAF factor usually rears its head when room treatments are involved.)
The Amati is a full range speaker. (And the Amati's does have significantly deeper bass than the Cremona's, given the twin 9" woofers versus the twin 7" woofers.)
I recommend finding some excuse to take your significant other on a vacation trip to a city that has a dealer(s) where you can listen to both speakers, (preferrably side by side).
Good Luck in your search!
However, if your room is already too bright sounding, using the Sophia II's might be slightly more problematic, (as I thought their treble response was a bit more extended than the Amati's); although room treatments can fairly easily tame brightness. (Assuming you can implement them; I've found that the WAF factor usually rears its head when room treatments are involved.)
The Amati is a full range speaker. (And the Amati's does have significantly deeper bass than the Cremona's, given the twin 9" woofers versus the twin 7" woofers.)
I recommend finding some excuse to take your significant other on a vacation trip to a city that has a dealer(s) where you can listen to both speakers, (preferrably side by side).
Good Luck in your search!