PS: Don't worry about the phantom power/48v. That only goes to the XLR input anyway, which you won't be using.
Actually, he would be using the XLR input because they are all built as XLR/TRS combo inputs. I don't know the impact of using phantom power on a microphone that doesn't need it, but I know that it will put a 48V DC current on the line (I have no information if this will damage a non-phantom power mic).
I would argue that a more "audiophile" solution would be something by RME, Universal Audio, Apogee, or MOTU
I had considered this, and the RME / Universal Audio solutions are definitely much more expensive and better sound quality than the Focusrite, but you are generally paying for a LOT more inputs and features. The OP doesn't need 8-16 input/outputs with multiple digital interfaces and mic/line drivers. The Black Lion device was actually built specifically for sound quality (my opinion that it is actually superior to any of the other general brands such as the ultra expensive RME). The $399 Black Lion Audio Revolution 2X2 has the exact same inputs/outputs/features as the $169 Focusrite, but it is built with audiophile level capacitors / DAC / etc. Black Lion has been in the industry for many years and their charter is to "audiophile" the studio type of equipment (even selling modification services for RME / MOTU / etc.).
However, as I re-read the original post, I don't think he will be spending as much as $399 anyways.