I think one of the reasons that bi-amping is a lightning rod is that there is much misinformation or opinion masquerading as fact.
People also mix non-compatible gear, like a fast SS amp with a 'slower' tube amp on the highs. (strongly held opinion) While not taking into account the latency of the amps being used, can introduce phase effects. (maybe testable)
The endless combinations of filter choices, points, slopes and type just feed the fires.
I'd suspect (again, opinion) that a properly setup (yet more opinion) bi-amp system could yield positive results.
I couldn't imagine my Panels NOT benefiting from a pair of same amps, given the close to 50:50 power distribution crossover point of 600hz.