It was also be advisable to confirm your recently jack-hammered Way out West LP is OK by tracking that passage with another pickup or two.
I like this idea above from @boothroyd. Do you have any local audio buddies with vinyl rigs that you could play that same passage to see if it mistracks on their set up?
If it’s not an A/S issue, could it possibly just be a bad vinyl pressing? It seems as though you do not have this issue on the majority of your other LP’s.
As a side note.... I have the original Naim ARO on my LP12 and absolutely love it! I'm happy to see that Naim is resurrecting this great arm.
Best wishes,
Don