Nicks or McVie.....


Which singer do the fine people of Audiogon prefer? In the past, personally, I always preferred the sound of Stevie Nicks. It was in the early 2000’s that the show South Park lured my mind into thinking Stevie Nicks sounded like a billy goat. Having mostly cleared my mind of such nonsense, McVie is still my preferred set of female vocals. Fleetwood Mac is a fine institution regardless of who happens to be on lead vocals.
128x128wturkey
If I have to pick one, it would be Christine McVie.   I really like her slightly raspy voice, and I love most of her writings in Fleetwood Mac.

Stevie Nicks has probably one of the most unique singing style/voice in rock.   It could be an acquired taste for some people, and I find it to be fatiguing at times.   But she's a fabulous backing vocalist on many of the Fleetwood Mac songs with McVie in the lead.

I'm not dismissing Stevie Nicks at all, and I do really like her voice.  I think having them both together is what made Fleetwood Mac such a successful band.

I saw/heard Buckingham & Nicks live in their local San Jose garage band---Fritz---in the summer of ’68 (the opening act at The Santa Clara County Folk/Rock Festival, the headliner the doors. The Electric Flag preceded the doors, and were a tough---impossible---act to follow). Just another local band, no better or worse than many others.

I didn’t hear of their 1973 debut album, but even if I did I wouldn’t have known they came out of Fritz. For some reason, very few San Jose bands had enough professional aspiration/ambition to make the move to L.A. (or perhaps self-confidence). Lindsey and Stevie did. I’m not certain, but I believe The Doobie Brothers got their Warner Brothers deal without making the move from SJ to LA.
"Its funny to read all the negative comments about one of the most beautiful singers of a generation"

Nicks fans always highlight her sexiness and looks.  Her evident pitch problems are the main reason I don't find her singing appealing. . . 
In the end, everyone's looks fade. I thought we were talking about vocal abilities, here.   
Both are great, McVie obviously less celebrated.

IMHO no one can match Linda Ronstadt's energy, quality and excellence in different types of songs and music. Not a bad looker either....I regret never having seen her live and really am sorry she has gotten ill and not been able to perform in a long time. But she recently one a big Kennedy Center award, so someone must agree with me.

That's singers only of course.....she never wrote much if anything.