Not in the least surprising, I doubt very few audiophiles have both state of art analog and digital setups, and even then, is that particular setup the objective arbiter. IME, analog better than digital, digital comes back and takes the lead, nope, analog retakes lead, digital comeback, etc. This over many years and many setups. Simply enjoy both and upgrade as needed, I don't get the angst over which format is best. Both are capable of artist in room amazement.
What is the reason for this? (Digital vs Vinyl Question)
I recently bought new speakers - GoldenEar Triton One.R towers - to pair with my Naim Uniti Star. My set-up for digital is the Naim with Ethernet, Qobuz & Tidal HiRes organized and played through Roon. With all of my other systems until now I preferred the sound of vinyl over digital. I have a Rega Planar 3 tt with Rega Fono preamp. I spin the highest quality records you can get - Mofi 1 Step, Analogue Productions, Classic Records, etc. etc. I've been listening for days trying to convince myself otherwise because of the $$ I've spent on records but the digital chain just sounds better to my ears. The question is: Is this because my new speakers are revealing the disparity between digital and analog better than lesser speakers I've used in the past (Monitor Silver, PSB Platinum, etc.) or is it because some speakers just match better with digital vs vinyl or is it because with the Naim streamer / DAC I've just put together a better digital front end and need to upgrade my tt and / or phono preamp?
- ...
- 48 posts total
Your new speakers are a more dynamic and full range speaker than you have had before so you will hear that the two formats will both sound very good at that point the better recording will win out and it will not matter what format it is on. The only thing i can say is that if you got a better phono pre amp your vinyl would sound a whole lot better and you did not mention the cartridge but if it is a rega you can switch to a dynavector 10x or 20 x and move to a whole new realm of sound on your table to. |
Digital can have more noise in it than analog. I'm not talking about ticks & pops while listening to a vinyl album, but general grunge. Note that this "grunge" (probably to strong of a word) may not even be noticeable to you... until it's gone. That stated, some equipment upgrades (amps, preamps, cables, conditioners, speakers) will help take that out of the system & as such, you'll notice more improvement with digital than analog. |
"Mofi 1 Step, Analogue Productions, Classic Records, etc" With all due respect to everyone who's weighed in on this so far, much of which I agree with, the problem is the records. These so called "Audiophile" records lack the very quality that makes analog so satisfying - TRANSPARENCY! I write about this a lot if you're interested: https://www.thebrokenrecord.net\ The records you play make a GINORMOUS difference in the experience you have with analog. Try buying one record from Better Records, just one, and see if your current analog front end doesn't start to impress you. If it doesn't you can return the record (30 day money back guarantee) and forget you ever read this. But if that record does turn out to pique your interest in the potential for vinyl again, then use THAT RECORD to decide what upgrades to make if and when you decide to upgrade your analog front end, or your electronics, or wires, or just about anything but the digital stuff. This is the way forward in analog. START WITH THE RECORDS! |
- 48 posts total