You could benefit from upgrading your server and upgrading your DAC. You will find the DSD is a wonderful unit but older. Newer units can give you more resolution and bigger, more engaging sound. I would encourage you to look at Bricasti. Both the M3 and M1 SE are big steps up from the DSD and Bricasti’s sound profile would strongly appeal to you. There are lots of other DAC options that would be a step forward, but my experience is Bricasti is an ideal next step for DSD owners.
a server will deliver a cleaner, clearer sound to your DAC. Something like the Playback Designs Syrah would be a very good choice given your preference for JRiver. You can consider other servers and software. Roon Core as the server using Squeeze as the interface is generally deemed a very good, if not best sounding option. For that, something like an Antipodes S40 or K30 would be excellent. I know those are radically different price points but you haven’t payed out a budget. S40 is good. K30 is great. K50 is elite. You get the idea.