How does solo piano help you evaluate audio gear?



A pianist friend just recommended this article and pianist to me, knowing that I'm presently doing a speaker shoot-out. My question to you all is this:

How important is solo piano recordings to your evaluation of audio equipment -- in relation to, say, orchestra, bass, voice, etc.? What, specifically, does piano reveal exceptionally well, to your ears?

Here's the article:

https://positive-feedback.com/reviews/music-reviews/magic-of-josep-colom/


 

128x128hilde45

I find a great test is plugging in my own keyboards (Technics P30 stage piano and Roland fp5) and it instantly exposes any weaknesses. Have a beautiful refurbed Brinsmead (great British make) upright fettled by an excellent tuner until funds stretch to a Bosendorfer.......

Post removed 

I apologize if i reacted a bit rudely but your post was a bit rude also... 😁😊

You seem to be a gentleman though...

I am more wired to understand people but i also  tend to react too swiftly ..

i understand you better now and i offer to you my deepest respect...

Sincerely yours...

 

Your past experience is welcome here for sure....

 

2ndly, when any poster here becomes impatient enough or high on his horse enough to begin his response with "for fucks sake" because of inner turbulence created by an answer contrary to his pre conceptions, that acts as an antagonist to my less than perfect side.

Is it right? no. I’m as imperfect as he.

I am not wired to "turn the other cheek".

I agree. Piano reproduction is very difficult task for audio system.

Especially for turntables and speakers.

I had a not cheap Nottingham Spacedeck turntable that was good for vocal, violin and orchestra BUT horrible for piano and pipe organ reproduction.

@hilde45

sounds like you are having fun... 👍

i think someone mentioned earlier that piano is also hard to mike, that and overall recording/mix quality is really important in how sound is then portrayed in room by a well set up system, i think that is what your experience thus far is highlighting (not to mention the challenges this poses to a system to handle transients, the full range of frequencies, overhang of notes etc)

i look at a piano, how big the enclosure is, say a grand with its lid open, the nature of direct, reflected, resonant sound, quite a complex set of sound waves emanating...