Any experience with Sound Smith repairing stylus on non-Sound Smith cartridges?

Peter did a retip on my Transfiguration and it came out great. As far as the original sound, you have to remember that by the time you send a cartridge in for a retip, it’s because the sound is off somewhat, so it’s hard to know. But it does sound excellent. And it was nice paying $500 instead of $5k for a new one. As far as what to do, I let Peter decide what was best. He ended up just doing the stylus and leaving everything else.

I had a Sumiko Blue Point Evo 3 that the cantilever had been broken off rebuilt and it came back sounding wonderful, I wouldn't hesitate to use Peter again.

I broke the cantilever on my Clearaudio Virtuouso Wood cart and had it rebuilt by Soundsmith.  It sounded great.  When I broke it again (arggh!), I sent it to Andy Kim, who was much faster and if I remember correctly, the price was a little less.  I recently sent a trashed Zu Denon DL 103 that came with a turntable I bought to Andy and it sounded amazing when he was done with it. 

Soundsmith does quality work and if that's your preference, I don't think you'll be disappointed.  Andy is another option worth considering.

Soundsmith retipped my Monster Cable Sigma Genesis 2000 cartridge (don't laugh, it was made by Zyx) and did a great job. It was not a fast turnaround, but within the time they estimated.

I would guess that SS does more retipping of other brands than it does on its own cartridges. You will be hard pressed to find a negative review of their work. In my case, I had them redo a Grace Ruby with sapphire cantilever and OCL stylus. (Original Ruby has elliptical stylus.) I am very pleased with results.