@sandthemall thx, I am just trying to be a perpetual student… I think everyone should DIY some audio gear…
best to all
jim
To Buy or to DIY, here is my question
If I buy the speakers that appear closest to what I desire
they are $11k new and $8k used.
If I buy the raw speakers and build it
the speakers alone are $2.2k.
That is a 3 way system.
Still must add costs of XOs and cabs.
Assume the total custom build cost would be about $3k.
The $8k speakers used are Proac D40Rs.
The raw components would be from ScanSpeak and SB acoustics
and include 10" woofer, 4.5" Mid and a planar ribbon tweeter.
MadiSound provides XO advice.
Comments???
@sandthemall thx, I am just trying to be a perpetual student… I think everyone should DIY some audio gear… best to all jim |
Okay time for some replies:
OldSchool- I built a dozen Owens Corning 703 2' x 4' panels 3 years ago. Nearly cried when I heard the improvement. Then again if I take my gear outside to the patio and listen, well I just want to move out there permanently.
Re all Altec Model 19 proponents. Agreed a great speaker. I owned the Altec Maestro 500s. Basically the 19 in a pro version. Modded them up and moved on.
If I build anything it will have only the best components and drivers. The XO will be designed by someone way better that most. Like Danny Richie. No-Rez inside and braced every which way.
Undecided whether to port or not.
Jonk & Phus- My goal is for the speaker to double as a toaster. Could not agree more with your perspectives.
Rustybut & Drumax- Funny you should include the Linkwitz photo from November in Heraldsburg. I was in the room. I liked the effect but those speakers have no presence in my book. Also too hideous to be allowed out in public.
Thanks for the support!!!
|
@gdaddy1 Thanks so much for taking the time to share your great tips. |
DIY is a process. And the process is it’s own reward. Since COVID hit, I’ve built several dozen pairs of speakers. DIY speakers are like potato chips. Once you start, it’s very difficult to stop after just one. Tuning a speaker will help teach you how to listen. Tiny changes in damping, stuffing, crossover components, crossover design will all show you what is, and is not possible to do. I would suggest starting, as others have suggested, with something simple. If you are handy and can build a square box with accurate dimensions and a couple of holes in it, there is no need to buy a flat pack. And start with an inexpensive design. Use inexpensive components. Think of this as a sketch, a playful experiment. Don’t expect it to be a showpiece out of the gate. Do expect to be surprised to find how little it takes to have something sound decent. That, and how difficult it is to make something truly exceptional. Keep it manageable, both from a technical build part and from an expenditure standpoint. The less stress you place on yourself for the first build, the more enjoyable it will be. What you learn from listening to the build will forever change how you listen to your system. You will literally be put inside the gear. |