On the face of it, a pertinent question but remember I said the Chesky disc was far worse than other CDs. So you can deduce the player paid other CDs satisfactorily.
To answer your question the player was a Wada 16, an expensive leading high-end CD player at the time. CDs did play much better on it than on cheapo Japanese tin boxes. The Wadia was my first CD player. I have only had one other, an Audio Research CD9. It is a good bit better than the Wadia.