Question Regarding New Item Damaged in Shipping


It's been a while since I've been active on this forum, and in audio.  I will not name names, will not provide additional information, my goal is not to sling mud, merely to understand if the practices of the "maker" and the "dealer" I am about to describe are, as the dealer is telling me, common in audio sales.

Facts:

I spent low 5 digits on a pair of mono block amplifiers. Shipped, they are 2 boxes of identical size and weight, about 85 lbs each. 

I did not use a credit card.

It appears that one of the boxes was damaged in shipping, however from the outside, it didn't / doesn't look like much of anything, however once the item is opened, you can see a little damage to the box, a little damage to the foam packing "clamshell", but not much.  

A speaker terminal was contacted by something sufficient to bend the chassis, and it isn't thin.  There's no marks of impact anywhere, it just looks as if pressure was applied to the terminal and the frame bent. 

All of my contact has been with the dealer. The dealer obtained a RMA, and asked me to ship the damaged mono back to the maker, at my expense, who will rebuild on a new chassis and send back to me at their expense.

I am being told that, despite the fact that the item was new when shipped to me "this is the way its done" in audio.  In other words, it is common practice among dealers and makers of high end audio to handle items damaged in shipping this way, and the buyer would bear the expense of getting the item to the maker for inspection and/or repair.

 

Is this accurate?

I appreciate any input you can provide.

 

 

gthirteen

was it not shipped with insurance? if insured, there should be no cost to you...

 

If you purchased this item as "new in box," then you are under no obligation to accept a repaired unit in its place. The component should be replaced with a factory fresh new unit.

A new item which is damaged should be replaced by the seller working through the mfg. They should also provide return shipping because this was NOT your fault. You contracted for a new item at an agreed price. You should never have to pay more for anything which was damaged.. Since you did not use a credit card, you have lost some ability to force the issue. It can be forced but it will probably take a state agency or lawyer. Maybe start with consumer protection in the sellers state and yours too.You may be able to appeal to

I just ran into this situation with a tube seller.

insurance is irrelevant.  That is something that the seller decides if he want's to minimize his risk.  

The seller is responsible for delivering an item to you that is not damaged.  Until that happens, it is his responsibility in full.

I would politely tell him that it is his responsibility.  Otherwise, you would be willing to accept a full refund.

Jerry