Anyone mention Phil Lesh?
- ...
- 120 posts total
@stuartk I’m rejecting any iteration of Stanley Clarke I’ve ever heard. If you have any suggestions, I’m all ears. I find that particular type of dentist’s-office-waiting-room smooth-jazz Muzak unendurable. It makes my soul hurt. I mentioned him by the self-evident merits of his technical proficiency. When addressing this thread, I tried to think of great non-classical, non-jazz bassists. I have a bass-playing friend who is extremely into the Jaco/Manhattan Transfer/Wooten/Clarke stuff. I perused those artists’ catalogs online again when trying to make my list, and I seemed to find Stanley’s output somehow slightly more unpalatable than people like Jaco, Wooten, and Flea. It’s difficult to reconcile an artists’ technical virtuosity with the disagreeableness of their music. I suppose when we say “best,” perhaps a qualification is necessary to define the terms. “Sheer technical proficiency,” or “makes you happy when listening,” or some combination of both. |
Thanks for the clarification. I feel the same way about “Sheer technical proficiency". The guitarists you mention and their ilk have never appealed to me because they fail to engage me emotionally. I find watching them more akin to witnessing an athletic competition than experiencing art. They do enjoy a very devoted following, though. Clarke was much more unambiguously Jazz-oriented early on in his career. For example, he was a member of the first (mostly) acoustic iteration of Return to Forever that released "Return to Forever" and "Light as a Feather". His playing in that group was much more supportive and does not display the extroverted Funk influenced "lead bass" approach for which he's best known. I have no idea whether you would enjoy these recordings and I'm not attempting to champion Clarke by any means-- simply pointing out that there is stylistic variation in his discography. |
@stuartk - there were a few mentions of Phil farther up the thread.... |
- 120 posts total