Cary Audio SA 200.2 SE power amp (latest version)


Hey there,

I need some advise and opinions on something. My current setup includes : Monitor Audio Gold 200 5g (latest generation), Classe Sigma Amp2 class D power amp, Classe Sigma preamp, Cary Audio CD 306 SACD player.
My speaker cables & XLR balanced analog interconnects are Cardas Clear Reflection. Power cables : Shunyata Delta NR, Transparent Reference PowerLink MM1, Audioquest Blizzard, Shunyata Venom V10 NR (20 Amp / C19) from wall to my Shunyata Venom PS8 AC power line distributor. AC power line distributor: Shunyata Venom PS8 with Venom Defender.

I’m about to pull a trigger on the new Cary Audio SA 200.2 SE power amp (latest version) to replace my existing Classe Sigma Amp2 class D amp. The Cary is a class AB amp. Which amp do you think will be a better choice for my system? Have anyone compared these two amps before and what are your thoughts? My Monitor Audio Gold 200 5g speakers (latest generation) are very laid back warm smooth refined sounding speakers. The highs and mids are very smooth. These new MA Gold 200 5g are complete opposite sound profile than the previous MA Gold 4g series, which are very forward and somewhat bright. And I’m using warm sounding speaker cables and analog XLR interconnects throughout.
Your advise, inputs and thoughts will be much appreciated. Thanks in advance.

dilatante

@dilatante Those should work nicely and a great match with your amp too. Nice. I had the Cardas GC and CR ic cables myself and can truly appreciate what you have there. I did have to get one pair Golden Cross reterminated once.  

So, this slight remaining hum still occurs on the right channel when the rest of the system is off, correct? Does the slight hum out of the right speaker still occur if the interconnects are disconnected and you power on the amp by itself?  And does the hum start out a little louder and quiet down after the first minute or two of power-on?  hmm.. just trying to think through it with you as you already sent it back/forth.  

@decooney 

The slight fain hum is there when all my equipments are turned on. Haven’t tried with everything else turned off but the power amp. But the faint buzz is only audible when I put my ear right up to the speaker and isn’t audible from say 2 feet away. But the other night after the amp was turned on for some 9 to 10 hours straight with playing music most of the time, and after 9 or 10 hours I noticed the buzz became a bit louder.

I had the Cary Audio SA 200.2.  I had the same buzz problem.  It was present on both channels.  It did not increase with volume.  It could be heard whether or not my Cary SLP-98P was powered up.  It was coming from the amp itself.  It could not be heard when music was playing.  The problem was once I knew it was there I couldn't unhear it, and it became bothersome.  

 

I contacted Cary for help.  I got this response focusing on the 3 wires connected to the PC board:

"We have learned the manufacture of these connectors used oil film coating on them for storage.  When the connectors are plugged into the board sometimes the metal doesn't make a good connection. To make a better connection we would pull the connectors off and push back on once or twice. By pulling off the connector and pushing back on the (2) metal pieces scrape and dig into each other making a very good connection. There are (2) amp modules. So one would have to do this for both channels."

I tried that.  It made no difference at all.  I eventually sold the amp.

Apart from that significant issue, the amp sounded very good.  If it weren't for that I'd likely still be using it.

 

This is a bummer learning more than a few of you experienced this humming issue on the non-ES and newer ES models of the SA-200.2  Mine was dead quiet, and reluctantly sold it.  What's concerning here is the initial response from Cary. May need to escalate it further.    If I still had my amp and it did this, it would be worth pushing on Cary Audio to send a repair white-paper with instructions for local service techs to help isolate, test, and fix this so called "oil films coating" connector issue. There may be a better way to get this coating off of the connectors, IF this is truly the root cause of the hum problem.   

At one point I thought about re-trying one of the newer ES amps yet after reading this, I'll wait.  One of you here (remaining ambassadors) who still owns one of these amps might want to reach out to owner and president Billy Wright to get him to come up with a solution. The hum noise is unacceptable for new amps.  Worth fixing locally vs. shipping back and forth, nice sounding amps.

@garyalex 

Yours is different. Yours is the original version of the SA 200.2, mine is the newer current SA 200.2 ES model. I sent it back to Cary and it’s quiet there when they put the amp in their listening room, so they couldn’t figure out what went wrong and so there’s nothing to be fixed and repaired. So they sent me a brand new SA 200.2 ES and they took my other amp in on a trade and they made me pay $1500 plus shipping towards a brand new amp. 
 

I have received the brand new amp 3 weeks ago and so far it’s been working flawlessly, no loud buzzing. It’s quiet. Wierd huh?