Hey Richard,
good to see you posting.
I agree, a lousy recording really spoils the listening experience.
But, I think some of that is due to the higher resolving nature of our systems.
Speaker tech, amp tech, preamp tech, etc. has never been as good as it is now.
Listening to the Rolling Stones shows me that they don't feel sound quality to be high on their list, compared to, say, Steely Dan whose Redbook tracks sound as good as high rez.
Bob