Streaming vs Physical Media


I have a decent digital front end with a Lumin U1 Mini (w/ external power supply) and a Border Patrol SE dac.  Have some CDs, but no transport.  Would a CD transport sound better than a streamer of similar quality/price?  

mdonda

When I was replacing my damaged speakers and cd player that stopped working,  I auditioned them at the time with a streamer and a sacd/cd player, both from Esoteric Audio.  My experience with streamers was limited at the time and upon hearing the first music out of it was surprised just how good it was; the dealer (I know these guys well)  even attached a Rubidium ( basically an atomic clock) based clock component, the size and impressively priced I might add to the rest of the components they make.  That took Mahler's Eighth to another level.  But the problems quickly showed their evil head.  Maybe two or three other bits of music were as good as the Mahler and even other symphonies from the same Mahler series were sonically different like sourced from a lesser quality source.  The sacd/cd player on the other hand made everything sound fun and I mean everything. When I came back on another day to get the speakers I brought cd's that I love, not audiophile stuff but things that I had purchased since the eighties and just love to listen to.  I guess I show my age but I have no problems preferring cd's, Lp's, sacd's, and even the occasional cassettes I made back in the eighties and nineties.  And with some of what I have read about some of the newer digital recording technology being suspect,  buying a new transport is a safe investment.  For me streaming would be more of a background listening thing and I like radio for that.  I hear enough new or unknown music to keep me engaged. 

And as a side note, I recently acquired a Magnavox( Philips) 560 cd player, about the earliest Philips TDA5141 chip based player, built-in august 1986 and made in Belgium.  This looks like my first machine; a modified version that was made by "The Mod Squad", at Music By The Sea, a former Steve McCormack company.  This though looks like it was sealed in a time capsule and in perfect or is as near mint condition that I have seen in the last few decades.  Even has the remote that looks unused and some original literature that came with it in near flawless shape. I always loved that/this machine from the Mod Squad until it stopped working twenty-five years ago.  The possibilities to improve it; discrete opamps, output caps, passive and active power supplies, etc., are endless but I'm keeping it stock.  I'll cleanup all the contacts and conectors and replace the (C7?) power cord with something better.  When I make some room on my equipment racks, I will place it with the rest of my main system, giving it the respect that I think it deserves.  I still can't get over just how clean it is.

My project rs2 sounds better than tidal masters or the same cd ripped to server... Makes no sense... But so for me I stream and if I really like album I buy it.... Also seeing the music better for memory 

@charles1dad 

Thanks for the recommendation.  That Taiko server certainly looks well-built and unique. I haven't read the reviews yet, but I will. 

I may have to wait for a good deal on a used one or until the tech makes it into less expensive servers.  I'd love to hear one, though

Thank you to all who posted - lots of good information and different approaches.

I ditched the CD player in the early 2000s - I burned my CDs and used an Apple TV with a hard drive as my music server in addition to my LPs.

I experimented with streaming in 2019 and the access to music drew me in.  

I listen to more digital than analog because of the amount of music available by streaming.  

I'd be biased towards focusing on streaming over CD transport based on the ability to discover new music.  

Just for some balance, there are quite a few audio enthusiasts whom understand IP networking who believe that audiophile routers and switches and signal reclocking dongles have no positive effect. 

there may be something to upgrade at the streamer end.  But the network before it should have no audio quality aspect except if you literally have dropouts.