Andrew
You and I had a little back and forth in the Letters section of Fanfare a few years back, and I respect your views. However I haven’t read TAS for a few years either. I was really turned off by the shilling for MQA. And I reject the fundamental premise of a system trying to realize “The Absolute Sound. “. Unless my listening room expands to the size of Chicago’s Symphony Center, my system will at best try to trick me with an illusion. And as for non Classical, who knows what is absolute? What comes out of the mix is whatever decisions the engineer makes.
You ridicule the “Consumer Reports” type of review. Surely we all would like to try each component in our own system and decide. Yet is this practical? Am I going to carry several different two hundred pound floorstanders up the stairs to my listening room and back out? Or will the likes of dCS let me audition a $100K DAC Stack in my own home and send it back 3 days later? Or does Air Force allow $150K turntables out of their factory for an audition?
The typical review will state something like “Peter McGraff of Wilson spent 3 days toeing in my Alexa’s until they were perfect”. Can a mere mortal such as I expect such service? Or else a reviewer might state “The amp made no sound when I turned it on so I emailed the CEO and 3 hours later a truck came with a replacement and the CEO flew in from Germany to plug it in for me”. I can’t even get Frigidaire to fix the ice maker in my refrigerator and it’s under warranty.
I think a few decades reviewing can warp the perspective here. Bricks and mortar stores have gone the way of the Studebaker. In the Covid era most people don’t want to see your face anyway. It is all very fine to be Altruistic and say “We ain’t Consumer Reports, do your own comparisons”. However most of us plebeian non reviewer types have very limited ways to make comparisons. This may explain some of the reason people become furious with dealers plugging their wares here, because actually evaluating these claims is so darn hard. We need more from reviewers than what you traditionally think is your purview. If we don’t get it, we turn elsewhere, and thus less TAS sales, less value for advertising, less money to pay for reviews