"...to find the one obscure situation where ASR measurements may not be correct, and attempt to use that as an excuse to discard all the work they do. Maybe that fools some people..."
I'm not trying to discount anybody's work or opinion. I'm just relating my experience. ASR doesn't really spend much time testing quality high-power amps or gear priced, let me be kind here, above the most modest level, just a few pieces. I like the measurements provided by ASR, but not much gear that I am interested in appears on ASR, so it's not particularly useful to me.