@peterayer . I think that could be a good idea to make a test in your room/system and this test is to listen the Rega RP-10 ( truly inexpensive for you at around 5.5K. ) with your today cartridges and find out which kind of differences you beeen aware vs your analog rig in use.
After the test you can put on sale and will goes fast or maybe you decide to keep it. A the end is just a subjective test as you like.
R.