Those singers you enjoy,....that don't really have a great voice?


There have been successful singers in almost any style that realistically did not have a "golden" voice.  Perhaps guilty pleasures.  Who are yours?

jusam

Tom Verlaine

David Bryne

Win Butler

Joe Strummer

Robert Smith

Satomi Matsuzaki

David Sylvian

Mary Timony

John King

Iggy Pop

Gary Newman

John Foxx

Robert Forster

Howard Devoto

Ian Dury

Jim Reid

Lloyd Cole

Robyn Hitchcock

Patti Smith

Jon Langford

Ian Hunter

David Thomas

Roger Waters

Snakerfinger

The Residents

Carrie Brownstein

Matt Johnson

Guy Kyser

Gordon Gano

When it comes to popular music hardly anyone can be called a great singer.

Cilla Black is ok on gentle ballads, as almost everyone else is too,  but on anything more physically challenging she transforms into 'Killa' Black as her voice turns into an unmelodic screech. Thankfully she still has some material worth listening to, as opposed to the likes of Billie Holiday or Adele whose voices seem mainly designed to inflict pain upon the listener.

 

Even worse, some of the very best lyricists and songwriters seem to have unpleasant voices which get increasingly unbearable when they're called upon to sing louder.

Elvis Costello

Bob Dylan

Bruce Springsteen

Bono

 

But then again not again everyone can be a Roy Orbison or a Robert Plant.

 

With Bob Dylan it's particularly bad on some of his live albums and 1980s work.

 

As an example you can compare his official release of 1975s Idiot Wind with the unreleased 1974 version.