I take his reviews with a grain of salt , everything is mostly good
how many times does he say something is bad ? I know of a couple reviewers
who would rather send the product back then give a bad review.
Guttenberg reviews Volti Razz
Just watched youtube review by Steve Guttenberg on the Volti Razz Decorator. (no veneer). In my view he sums up all I've been enjoying with these wonderful speakers. Dynamic, sweet sounding, engaging, musical...
Decorator Razz, $2k less than standard Razz. DIY stain and seal. Pretty darn cool in my book!
Volti has one flaw ,myself. Modding Xovers for over 20 years not only volti but the vast majority ,they use average at best parts quality why ? and know most are subpar ,the Xover is the ♥️ or 🧠 of any loudspeaker good or bad , having owned a Audio store ,I know all too well ,for speakers and electronics only 25% goes into the product including packaging ,the rest R&D overhear and markup this is why unless you spend $$ your much better taking a solid design and have it modded , for mfg use a 4-1 markup ratio cables can be far Worcester 10-1 ratio they can charge $$& anything they want for their time and wire geometry, I use good wire with sound geometries like Wireworld ,Audio quest. Who have been there ,Cardas , a Litz wire I prefer ,others buy what they like, |
@audioman58 Good point and good advice. For myself when I'm in the market for something I read and listen to as many points of view as I can. Of course also here on AG. Then if there seems to be a mostly positive consensus and no glaring flags, I set off to use my own ears. When I was in my favorite college job, one of the only two high end shops in my town, my boss noted I read every audio rag out there, Sterophile, TAS, HiFi Choice, etc... He said something along the lines that there is a mutual relationship there. Reviewer's need companies to send gear to review to sell copy, companies need reviews to sell gear. Reviewer too harsh = less gear sent = less gear and magazines sold. |
@audioman58 and one of them is Steve Guttenberg. He said so himself. Steve actually stated recently-ish that if a product he has would be getting a bad review from him, he opts to send the unit back to manufacturer and skips doing a review. His stated reason was not wanting to take part in a taking down or hurting a business. He simply prefers to only review things that will be a good review… I’ve seen Steve hit the nail right on the head describing a unit I am also familiar with, like the OP says, too. With that said, I don’t think he’s untrustworthy just because he likes to review in a positive manor. He’s still gets it right and does still mention ‘negatives’ that may be helpful to someone. |
Doyle3433 Very good points As I said when selling gear. 1 review is just one’s opinion , multiple reviews from several different sources are a more accurate consensus. I have heard Horror stories one from a excellent company years ago who was Called ESP. Their concert grands, and Harps outstanding , the 2 Biggest audio magazines said give us $50 k and you will have superb positive coverage ,sadly he was just growing not like B&W ,Wilson who had deep pockets came up with 20% of that he received a decent review and little coverage and being speaker of the year in I think Fi magazine later 90s he had to shut down and moved back to Ireland . I bought a pair they were fabulous until they were destroyed in a fire. This happens to many products , look for return policies and auditions . These big companies 30% of the markup is their advertising ,please keep this in mind . Thsts why for now the Dynaudio floor standersi rebuilt are staying put I put Svs 4000 sub ,maybe adding a 2nd one and they sound better then anything over $12k+ the Xover was the weak link they had $400 in parts I spent $1600 a mfg would charge $6k 4-1 ratio , which wouldnot happen ,many use the cheaper Mundorf Evo white capacitors when in fact their Black Supreme are by far their best , and their $4 mox resistors , they make $30 ultra you are seeing in the Magico A5 .I use the excellent Path audio around $30 each quality counts ,as well as connectors most companies use bright gold over brass connectors ,I use WBT , and why on amplifiers would you create a bottle neck for $25 a Furutech gold Copper IEC is 4 x better conductivity far less noise resistance ,they use a $3 plated brass , it makes no sense just to save a few bucks judt charge the extra in the build ,pennywise pound foolish . I change. Many things myself , I hate when mfg think of $$ before quality. |