If you want lame advice DON'T do this!


Have you ever seen a member ask for advice about their system and don't understand why they need to make a change? Mistakes in this hobby are generally expensive. Does a list of components tell you how they sound together as a system? No Does a picture of a room tell you how the system sounds in the room? No. Think about the dollars that have been flushed away because the problem was the room and no matter what you stick in there or how much it cost it won't git er done. A flat in room frequency response is a starting point before changing anything. So, why don't more people post measurements when asking for advice? If you want lame advice DON'T post your system in your profile. If you want good advice post your system and a pic. If you want excellent advice include your in room FR measurements (which almost all modern receivers provide or REW can do for free). 

kota1

@mahgister 

Is the OP an acoustician specialized in small room

That is a GREAT question. The OP (as in moi) knew his limitations re: small room acoustics AND his budget. Thankfully I had the sense to get the acoustics right before blowing up my budget. There is some GREAT info available on the topic which I chose to avail myself of. (check page 2 here) and (chapters 4,5, and 10 here) This is a starting point and yes, I consulted with professional mixing stages, studio owners, the founder of Auro 3D, and installers of high end listening rooms and home theaters. I have had my measurements reviewed by professional acousticians. Maybe it was overkill but still a LOT cheaper than buying new gear. 

You are completely right about the importance of acoustic over even gear choice as the road to audiophile experience...

Thanks for the articles...

😊

 

@mahgister

Is the OP an acoustician specialized in small room

That is a GREAT question. The OP (as in moi) knew his limitations re: small room acoustics AND his budget. Thankfully I had the sense to get the acoustics right before blowing up my budget. There is some GREAT info available on the topic which I chose to avail myself of. (check page 2 here) and (chapters 4,5, and 10 here) This is a starting point and yes, I consulted with professional mixing stages, studio owners, the founder of Auro 3D, and installers of high end listening rooms and home theaters. I have had my measurements reviewed by professional acousticians. Maybe it was overkill but still a LOT cheaper than buying new gear.

It’s always a good idea to NOT make recommendations without knowing more about the context in which the recommended component will be operating.

I agree the result can often be money wasted, depending on exactly how one goes about it. The main thing is to buy things that can be returned or resold cost effectively if needed because you never know for sure until its operating in YOUR room.

Given that, the smart thing for even high end affectionados to do is try less costly products that have good chance of doing the job well first before trying to go for broke.  You can always make a change as needed.  Otherwise you may be spending a lot for something that might have been achieved for much less.

How many here actually do that?  Don't know except that I do.

 

@newbee

And the bigger question is, perhaps, who is going to train these folks?

I wouldn’t want to send out a drivers ed student in a Rolls Royce. If you are Joe Six pack just install big subwoofers and hit the only switch you will ever need (full blast). Next there are certified calibrators that will calibrate a TV or a listening room (see CEDIA and https://homeacoustics.org/haa-training/)

For the astute members that have already invested in a system it isn’t a big deal to buy a mic and measure.

@mapman 

It’s always a good idea to NOT make recommendations without knowing more

Thank you, 👍