What makes One Music Server Sound Better than Another?


So this week my Mojo Audio DejaVu music server that I have used for the past 2-3 years crapped out. Benjamin at Mojo was more than helpful and the DejaVu is on its way to Mojo Audio where it will make a full recovery.

Thankfully, I still have my Antipodes DX2 Gen 3 (their former flagship) music server so I hooked it up. After wrestling with Roon protocols, transfers, and set-up menus, I was able to get it going so I have music. The DX and my Sonore Sig Rendu SE opt. are both connected to my network so the DX (like the DejaVu), is only being used as a Roon core and the Sig Rendu SE serves as the Roon endpoint for streaming Tidal and Qobuz, with a direct USB connection to my DAC.

The point of this thread is to ask, how come I perceive the the DejaVu server as sounding better than the Antipdes DX? In fairness, the differences I perceive are not great but it seems the DejaVu is fuller sounding, more tonally rich, and bolder. Is this why some here spend $10K+ on a Grimm, Taiko or something else?

If a server is basically a computer, sending digital information to a streamer/endpoint and, assuming that digital information is transmitted asynchronously and reclocked by the DAC’s master clock, and assuming noise is not the issue (i.e., both units are quiet and there is an optical break between the network and both the server and endpoint) then what are the technical reasons one should sound better than the other? It is not that I want to spend $10K+ on a music server with a lifespan of maybe 5 years before becoming obsolete, but I would like to understand what more you are getting for your money. So far, the best I can come up with is lower internal noise as the major factor.

As a side note to the above, when I thought things looked hopeless for getting set up, I scheduled a support session with Antipodes and, although I lucked into the solution before the meeting time, Mark Cole responded ready to help. Setting up the session was super easy and reminded me of the superior level of support I had come to enjoy from Antipodes during the time that the DX was my primary server, including multiple updates and 2 or 3 hardware upgrades, which prolonged the service life of the DX. Good products and good company.

 

mitch2

Totally agree that you can spend a lot less on the digital side and have a state of the art digital front end. 

Not in my experience.

Question:  Which do you spend more time sitting down and critically listening to- your digital or your analog playback?

Because, until I really went in deep with the digital side, I would play 1/2-1 CD to warm the system up before putting on a record.  As the digital side got better I could spend more time listening to it.  If you have a decent analog front end I would think that you could tell a difference in the rhythm and pace between the digital side and analog side.  I think that is one of the differences that gets me sitting spellbound now listening to digital playback.

@tonywinga 

Pretty sure you’re not talking about me, right?  

First, I have about $100k invested in 4 systems, over $80k of which is in my two reference level systems (including cables).  Second, I have 4 different DACs in those 4 systems, and have experience with several other DACs over the last 23 years.  Third, I don’t have a “Raspberry NUC streamer”, though I did assemble and deploy a Raspberry Pi streamer in three of my systems as a fun experiment; I’ve since given the Pi to my son in law, who is repurposing it for his home security system.  Fourth, I am very far removed from being part of any “IT crowd”; just ask my wife.  In retirement (from a career in finance and policy), I now provide IT support to my wife, who is an attorney and works alot from home.  It ain’t pretty!  

Finally, since when do we get to dismiss anyone’s experience and views, whether or not they’re in the minority in one thread on one forum? (And btw, it’s not even clear that I’m in the minority on this thread; voting loudly still just gives you one vote.)

I know you are not part of the IT crowd.  Just keep an open mind about digital.  It is a much different animal than analog.  In Analog, less is more but that is not always the case on the digital side. And “noise” in the digital realm is not the same as hiss in the analog realm.   While noise in both realms reduces resolution, it does much more damage to the music on the digital side.  

I can't think about what I have spent on my system.  My midwestern, pragmatic upbringing screams at me for being so extravagant.  I just ordered a second SSD for the K50 music server.  My left brain and right brain were duking it out until I finally managed to hit the enter key.  But I love music and this hobby. It made the hard times bearable over the years.