I Don't Understand What Determines When A Thread Gets The Axe

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

allenf1963

... there just seems to be a lot of discussions shut down, deleted, etc., over the last 5 years and for the life of me, I couldn’t figure out why. I have actually asked the question, but never got an answer ...

If you use the Contact Us link that is at the bottom of each page, you'll quickly receive an automated reply with a ticket number followed by a personal email from the moderator and, eventually, an automated user feedback form. That's at least three contacts for each inquiry. Something's wrong if that wasn't your result, e.g. the messages went to your spam folder, or perhaps you've confused A'gon with another audio site.

I don't notice many threads being deleted. But I tend to avoid contentious threads and I usually ignore users that seem problematic, so perhaps that explains it.

The angst over this particular deleted thread mostly overlooks the fact that the thread's OP made specific accusations of fraud and stated it was to be a repository for future such claims. That is a very distinct difference than accusing someone of shoddy service or botching an order and creates liability problems for A'gon.

A'gon allows discussion that is critical of dealers and manufacturers, but there's a limit. The post under review here was properly removed, imo.

@cleeds You do seem to be the most righteous member of Audiogon having luxury of receiving answers on why your post or discussion is getting removed. I'm not sure if there are more members with such privilege, but for us "simple folks" discussions and posts being removed either with auto-answer or with no answer at all whether we use Contact Us link or don't

I too want to give you medal for that -- how about "Honored Audiogon Member Veteran", because you really deserve it!

As for you @allenf1963 , you can clearly see what's happening. After the post removed, just try to "play" with different words so you can beat the underdeveloped algorithm of Audiogon. It often works. Looks like word Fraud is too political so you can use wrongly spelled version like "FROD" as an example, or replace with less heavy synonyms. 

czarivey

You do seem to be the most righteous member of Audiogon having luxury of receiving answers on why your post or discussion is getting removed. I'm not sure if there are more members with such privilege ...

While I've always been treated fairly and courteously by Audiogon staff, I don't think I've received any privileged treatment. I know a few other A'gon users "in real life," so I know my experience isn't unique.

Because there are certain people who register fresh and post inciting videos. Did you see the thread that got axed yesterday? That same person has opened a new one today, though the good thing is no one care anything about it.

You want active moderation?  Try Roon's forum.  They have a huge number of moderators who appear to move posts into different threads constantly.  It's super confusing because they'll move a post out and start a new thread with it when the poster had no intention of starting a thread, and then the poster gets grief for starting the thread.

That's not to say the mods don't perform a valuable service, but there is such a thing as over moderation.  The difference with Roon is that the forum software is much more sophisticated and can help you retrace steps and see what happened.  The Audiogon forum does feel more basic in its function.