Crossovers? How do you evaluate if crossover is any good?


I hear Crossover designs are very important to your system. You have several drivers in a speaker and I've seen the curve designs where they slope up and down and when overlaid on top of the curve of another frequency ranged driver they overlap a little bit as slopes go up and down.

So what does all this mean and aren't speakers generally designed similar to other speakers in this area. Is it all about designing the curve? Exactly what is it that makes a crossover better than another crossover?

 

emergingsoul

Hey.... psst.... buddy, don’t you really want to make your own speaker?? You really do.... :D Check out Madisound or Parts Express for a number of pre-designed kits.

The cabinet, drivers and crossover form an integrated system. Voicing is important and can make one speaker have a distinct personality from another. As a consumer, what matters most for you is the end result.

After voicing, the next things you might care about is the impedance curve, and the off-axis response to tell you something about the drivers and how well they were put together.

Somewhere in here part quality matters as well, with a very wide range in cost and quality.  Some basic speakers, like Wharferdale Diamonds or low-end Focals really benefit a lot from tweeter cap upgrades in the neighborhood of $10-20 a speaker. 

Caps are probably the part of the crossover that can impart the most character.  Top end Mundorf is used by Magico and B&W for a reason, and while colorful not for me, per se. 

Experimenting with caps early on is best done with self-made kits rather than expensive store bought speakers, and I think it's fun and you can learn a great deal more that way than by reading.

I stopped using crossovers 20+ years ago, though the whizzer cone is sort of a mechanical crossover.

 

 

DeKay

@emergingsoul -- I know you like stirring the pot, but why are you posting a question about speaker crossovers on the amp forum and not the speaker forum?