I think a lot has to do with the source of the recording. When it was mastered , who mastered it…. Etc. There are many copies of the “same” album when you search. Some are phenomenal, some are pretty bad.
I have a lot of CDs that were AAD recordings and they don’t have compression like many recording today. Some sound really good .
I love streaming , don’t get me wrong , it totally changed the was I consume new music. But I like the ritual of CDs and records.