New or Old DAC

This question, new vs. old DAC, has been asked many times before, I suggest you search the Digital archives.

To some up all previous post, there is no 'right' choice. Some prefer the superior digital section of the newer models, and some prefer the superior analog output section of the older models. You pays your money, you makes your choices....happy hunting.

Cheers,
John

I can't see any reason why an older model would have a "superior" analog section? I can't imagine that any older DAC could hold a candle to current models.

The improvements in digital processing are an order of magnitude better in new DAC's and I can't see that there has been any regression in analog technology. It is either equal to, or quite probably better, depending on the company.

I would say that if you get a Benchmark, Bel Canto, Cary, Bryston, or similar you will be shocked at the improvement.

Good luck.

I am currently using a Cambridge Dacmagic. I can honestly say, after owning numerous high quality DAC's, this one is much better in ALL respects. Previous DAC's owned: Levinson 36, Classe DAC-1, Electrocompaniet, EAC DSP-7000 and Parasound DAC-2000.
As per the previous replies, I would look for a newer designed unit. I highly recommend the Dacmagic.

i personally think older theta dacs do rival and outperform many of the current dacs. they are not your typical dac animal and unless you have had one, it is hard to understand that. if you already know you like that sound, go for it...or save up for a gen viii2! i am in a similar circumstance and am pretty sure i will be getting a cb3 next (moving from casanova) but likely preowned with older dacs.

08-31-09: Macdadtexas
I can't see any reason why an older model would have a "superior" analog section? I can't imagine that any older DAC could hold a candle to current models.

The reason behind this philosophy is depreciation. Digital gear depreciates rapidly, like computers. So you are not comparing a $1K current model to a 5 year old $1K model, you are comparing a $1K current model to a $4K 5 year old model, which will sell used today for about $1K.

A $4K DAC will have better materials, expecially in the analog output stage than a $1K DAC. This was true 10 years ago, 5 years ago and today. Some feel that the latest digital chips make all the difference, (such as yourself). Some feel that the newer chips are just buzz-kill for the computer generation, and that the analog output stage is the most important part of a DAC (such as myself).

Remember, no one puts tubes, fancy caps or resistors in the digital to analog convertor, these premium parts go in the analog output stage.

Using automobiles as an analogy, it's like choosing whether to buy a new Kia with a powerful V12 engine in it, or a older used Porsche with a V8 in it......same price for either. Each will have it's proponants.

Cheers,
John