Tweeters with or without fluid?


Happy New year to all and all the best in the new year. Looking for all the input out there on the question that tweeters with a cooling fluid or no fluid. The benefits and the drawbacks thank you to all who respond.

dickface

Ferrofluid can help flatten the impedance curve and reduce Fs and diaphragm excursions, but each design is different and handles those potential issues differently, so it’s use isn’t universally advantages.

I changed out the FF on my 30 year old Seas domes a few years ago, and it made an audible improvement after.

It’s fallen pretty much out of favor. The biggest advantage today is higher power handling, which for home listening is usually not a big concern. I doubt most home tweeters ever see more than 3 W honestly.

One big disadvantage is that it dries out and gums up the magnet cavity and voice coil requiring replacement AND cleaning.

Like @knotscott said, if your tweeter was designed for FF you definitely need to maintain it as intended.

Here’s a good article on the subject.though I don't necessarily agree that all tweeters should have some.

Like every other type of technology buzz word, take it with a grain of salt and evaluate the finished product, not the buzz words.

Not exactly a scientific poll, but of about 160 tweeters available at Madisound only about 30 advertise the use of ferrofluid. 

Thank you for your thoughts on this, I was only aware of the fluid drying out. Never realized it was a maintenance item, not surprised to hear pros and cons of no fluid or with. @erik_squires  Sir you are magical at your explanations I quite enjoy this forum and you are one of the reasons I keep reading.  Thank you again to everyone. I wish for everyone here on audiogon, a happy, healthy and musical filled 2025.

@dickface - Obviously your mileage may vary, but search DIYaudio and you’ll find lots of discussions about cleaning out old tweeter voice coils with dirty or gummed up ferrofluid. That’s the only reason I know about this.

I don’t know however how much better a certain brand or model of modern FF using tweeter is vs. the early days, but certainly some top brands still have a couple of models which rely on it, and they also tend to be high power versions, which given how efficient the modern tweeter is, really are for very high output systems.