We cannot deny that there is as much musicians of genius today as in the past...
It is evident,...
It is evident also that corporations manufacture the singers, the musicians the public and the product to some great extent and sometimes completely way more today than by the past ...
It is also evident that there is music garbage very well done in a professional way in the past as today...
It is evident than there is garbage not so well done yesterday as today...
Yes i am an old dude complaining as Beato did...So what ? I like his sincerity by the way...
But i just wrote a precise sociological argument : Manufacture of singers,musicians,products and especially manufacture of many, many niches products for an atomized public reduced in tribes by corporation fine tuning the medias which they control pretty well...The listeners and the public is then manufactured also and way less homogenous than 80 years ago.
Then there is way less place for the artist creativity and originality if he want to eat, he must choose between integrating a machine in some niche or goes independent.....
An artist who became a machine is at risk to loose his genius... Some can survive to this by developing big turn at 90 degree in their style, but you must be a genius to let your created loving public behind your race toward your own musical goal as Bob Dylan was able to do and some others, freeing themselves... Madonna is the same machine as she was since the beginning.Big talent no genius.
When Beato talk about how easier it is to make music today, he say the same thing than me about "manufacturing" everything even the artist.
Talking shit about Beato will not change this fact...
The grumpier dude here are perhaps not me nor Beato but those who do ad hominem attack instead of "thinking" ...
Technology made everything easier at the cost of replacing human imperfection by a perfect mechanization of our gestures. This is Beato point. And he is right.
Machine perfect gesture kill art expression because it kill the subtle very meaningful microdynamic controlled imperfection which is the breathing of art.
I bet those who disparaged Beato video as a Grumpy man rant did not listen the video accurate content or worst dont understood his points..
His last point : music is too easy to consume nowadays and it may destruct some of his value it for sure right...
It make music a product as anything else not a revered sacred creation which we must work hard to own. Then it motivate the producers to produce more garbage to consume in the continuous " faucet" of Spotify or other medias.
Beato video is excellent and on the point...