Warm sounding phono cartridge


Hello all.  I recently upgraded the phono cartridge on my Marantz TT15S1 from the Clearaudio cartridge that came with the table to a Hana Umami Blue.  I'm overall happy with the purchase.  However, while the Hana has made my well cared for and well recorded LP's sound excellent many of my albums now sound thin to me and noisy. Clicks and pops have been exacerbated to the point that I do not want to play some records even after a run through my Degritter ultrasonic.

I'm looking for a phono cartridge MM, MC or MI in the $1,000 range or less that is warm sounding and less revealing than the Hana.  Any thoughts?  

rfauto

my well cared for and well recorded LP's sound excellent many of my albums now sound thin to me and noisy. Clicks and pops have been exacerbated to the point that I do not want to play some records even after a run through my Degritter ultrasonic.

Two possible problems can cause this. Your phono preamp isn't dealing well with the noise and needs upgrading. Or your well cared for albumin have groove damage due to previous play with worn stylus.

You may consider a Benz Micro cartridge if it's the cartridge fault. But I don't think it's your cartridge at fault.

 

Clicks and pops after ultrasonic cleaning either suggest really poor quality or damaged vinyl records, or something is off with your cleaning procedure.

Re thin sound, consider experimenting with loading setting on your phono stage. I don't know recommended loadings for your two carts and what your PS has as options. I also found that putting a SUT between MC cart and MM-in of PS generates a fuller sound.

Also adjusting tracking force may change the sound quite a bit. VTA for some has a strong effect; I could not hear anything.

I have 2 phono stages.  A Manley Chinook and a Hegel V10.  I have played with the loading on both and get similar results. Although the Hegel seems to have less top and bottom to me than the Manley.  A good example is I just bought a Jackson Browne Somebody's Baby 12' Single Promo Released in 1982.  The condition is very good.  The album is quiet but sounds thin to me using the Hana.  A lot of the albums that I own of that vintage seem to have a similar sound to them.  Is there a cartridge that can add some color and fullness?  Something that is easy to listen to that doesn't necessarily add a lot of detail.

@artemus_5 It could possibly be due to the cartridge change.

When I upgraded from a Dynavector XV-1s to a Lyra Atlas I was amazed at how much less I noticed ticks and pops on my old records. As if they had disappeared. Someone I know at Audio Quest who used to handle the Lyra line explained it this way,

I think what you are hearing re ticks is the fact that the Lyra has a much faster transient response, which also means it has less overhang. Tics and pops start and stop very quickly and have less audible impact on what you hear.

It may just come down to differences in the cartridges. A less resolving cartridge may or may not be the answer

I have a Hana ML cartridge and I don't have an issue with popping or thin sound. I use a Sutherland TZ Vibe photo stage.  I just listened to it last night and it sounds great.