Audio Technica AT 1005 ii or Fidelity Research FR54?


I'm currently using the Audio Technica AT1005 ii arm on my upgraded Lenco L70.  I bought the table without a tonearm and I read on the Lenco Heaven threads that the AT 1005 was a drop in replacement for the L70 arm.  However, it appears that the pivot to spindle distance on the AT is 225mm whereas the ideal pivot to spindle distance on the L70 is 230mm.  I was looking at perhaps trying the FR54 arm since it has a 230 pivot to spindle distance and they are relatively inexpensive.  I'm using mainly a Rega Apheta 2 (medium compliance cart) and sometimes a Denon 103R (low compliance).  The Rega is mounted on a lighter headshell than the Denon to try and maximize synergy with the heavy AT arm.  Any opinions?  Would I notice the 5 mm change in pivot to spindle?  I can dial in my alignment just fine but the cartridges are definitely at the tip of the headshells.  Would this be more of a lateral move in terms of quality of sound?  I know there are better, more expensive options out there (groovetracer, schick) but I'm not ready to lay down that kind of money right now.  Thanks

adam8179

+1 for the Fidelity Research 54 arm. I have one, along with the FR29. Both are excellent arms available for affordable prices!

Do It Right!

I was able to slightly elongate an existing hole (from 40mm round to 40mm x 45mm oval). It was centered at 230mm, I eased it bigger (toward the spindle only) to allow my 225mm arm to be properly located. (rear Acos Lustre GST-801).

It’s base plate covers the entire hole, but you can always make a thin hardwood or metal spacer or find a very large washer.

The arm’s hardware on threaded post tightened it properly from below. If a 3 screw Jelco type surface mount like my Blackbird, you can rotate so the screws find fresh wood. My left side Mission arm was tapped for machine screws from below. I drilled the holes all the way thru and made it like a Jelco Surface Mount, painted some wood screws black, done.

My 12.5" long arm, I rotated the removable rectangular arm board and drilled a new hole for it’s small diameter post and surface mtd. base. I made a 1/8" recessed plug for the old hole (simply taped in place from below so hole can be used if desired) and put a 45 rpm adapter in it to make it appear purposeful.

Elongating the hole: I clamped 1-1/2" thick wood on top of the arm board, so the new hole thru that 1-1/2" would guide the bit as it passed off-center thru the original hole, easing one edge only.

It was fun solving things, and knowing they are correctly located personally.

The 3rd arm on the left: I had to find an arm with a very short counterweight section, luckily the seller knew how to measure and give me the needed answers, there is only about 1/8" clearance when the arm is parked and the thick dust cover is on. Small diameter base was needed, it just fits very close to the wide rim of the JVC TT81.

I was going to move to a CL-P3 3 arm plinth, at the last minute, I got an answer from the seller in Hong Kong. I realized, I could not put my 12.5" Blackbird arm on the right side arm board of the CL-P3, because they modified the plinth and arm board, cut it’s shape and moved the armboard cutout inwards closer to the TT, to make room to add the 3rd removable arm board on the left side. My 12.5" arm is too long for it, it only fits on my CL-P2. Dumb luck, I got a lot of that.

The only thing that precise pivot to spindle distance does is allow for correct alignment at the stylus location.  If you are able to align correctly, the pivot to spindle distance is correct.  Changing arms will change the sound, but the pivot to spindle differences are irrelevant if you can align correctly.

Bill

Thanks guys.  It looks like I'm getting ok alignment with my cartridge by mounting it pretty near the end of the head shell and tilting it slightly.  (at least that what my alignment protractor is telling me).  I very well may just go ahead and get the FR54 just to satisfy my curiosity.  It's a very pretty arm and affordable!  Can't really tell which would be better without hearing them