You can really knock yourself out comparing vibrapods, all the different elastomer pucks, cones of different materials... etc. I have a couple drawers of this stuff. I spend probably hundreds of hours or more doing detailed comparisons over the decades.
A very generalized conclusion I came to is that the very expensive stuff... like Townsend, Silent Running Audio, and Black Diamond work better than cheap stuff. It’s really simple, companies like these that do Research and Development can/must produce products that are very notably superior to someone who simply chooses a substance and makes it into a form. Companies like Townsend and Silent Running have outstanding reputations for a reason. Folks that can afford them hear the difference.
I was young and poor once and worked my way through inexpensive alternatives. Nothing wrong with that.