Speakers "Too Big" for room


I have an office with KEF LS50 speakers. I’m gonna try to move in some large Infinity full-range speakers. Typically, conventional wisdom would say that these speakers are too big for the room. I’ll know for sure how they will sound but, why would anyone say that. Why can’t you put large speakers in a small room???

pawlowski6132

Looks good and glad to hear it sounds good.  Speakers too big - clickbait to any audiophile.  If you can get them through the door they’re not too big.  If they don’t fit, you need a bigger room.  

@devinplombier

Yes!! I have a modified Carver with the following specs.

8 ohms       460 watts < 0.15% THD
4 ohms    

  510 watts < 0.15% THD

Dynamic      
8 ohms       700 watts
4 ohms     1000 watts
2 ohms     1290 watt

 

Here's the detail of the mod

https://nelionaudio.com/index.php?/services.html/carver/carver-amplifiers/carver-m-10t-mkii-opt002-restore-and-upgrade-r3/

Also, fwiw, 95% of what I listen to is voice and small ensemble acoustic instruments at medium volumes. So far so good.

 

 

 

 

 

 

I love the room. It looks like a great place to hang out. Great looking system as well. 

As you probably know, there is tremendous opportunity to improve sound quality through acoustic treatment. A larger rectangular highly absorbent rug. I think there are ways of making the curtains highly acoustically absorbent... so when you wan to critically listen you close them. Put flat absorbent panels behind, And these don't screw up the charm of the room. 

 

Enjoy the music!

@zx10 Wrote:

My L.R. is about 16'X14' and would love to have a pair of JBL L-300's or 4333's but it just doesn't seem like the room's big enough for them. So I have JBL L-100T's with updated crossovers 

I had my JBL 4430's in a 14'x16'x9' room. I also had my JBL L65's, JBL 4315's in the same room. I will note that you can sit in close proximity to the 4430's, 4435's and 4425's with no loss of stereo image see here and here. For in the what it's worth category, there is no perfect room! 😎

Enjoy the journey.

Mike

@pawlowski6132 

The only germane data point I can offer is that I tried a stock Carver M500 with my RS-II, and it was immediately clear that better amplification would be needed. Currently I am running Classé monoblocks that are up to the task, but I can't say they have too much power.

I'm familiar with Nelion but I have no direct experience with their mods. Looking at the power claims they make though, I would venture that they perpetuate Bob Carver's legacy in more ways than one 😀

Based on your musical preferences and expected listening sound levels, your modified Carver will most likely drive your speakers to your satisfaction. Enjoy!