$3,500 for analog front end

Call Jim Hudson at Hudson Audio (do a Google search) for Huson Audio)and discuss the Scheu Turntables. They are German made with quality bearings, motors and platters. The Cello and the Premier MKII would fit your budget, get a used Graham Slee ERA GOLD V phono stage for around $600.00 or a Jolida JD-9 which is very flexible and good while inexpensive (lots of loading options)then modify the caps and the Op Amps and change the tubes. The Denon DL-103 is good and cheap, Cinemag tranformers for step-up. Buy used when you can to stretch your budget. Good luck.

While it is hard for claim that any one setup will be best, it is hard in that price range for anything to compete with a Nottingham Space Deck & matching Nottingham arm, and either a Shelter 501, or Dynavector 17DmkII cartridge. Tons of phono stages to fit the bill, but a Blue Circle BC27 is a good bet for not too much money.

I second the Spacedeck/ Shelter or Dynavector
or Sumiko Blackbird

As far as a phono pre, I'm in purchase mode on a major upgrade to a low output MC system. I have an Audio Research PH2, built like a tank that would mate great with your system (MM, HoMC). Search the archives, it has great tonal balance and dead quiet, if interested contact me.

thanks
Tom

i think audiofiel gave excellent advice.follow it like he says and you should be happy with the results.