Turntable/Tonearm Advice


I'm considering one of the following combinations and would appreciate comments from anyone familiar with these. There are no SOTA or OL dealers near me, so I can't listen to any of these (I've never even seen OL gear).

Origin Live Resolution/Origin Live Illustrious MK3
SOTA Sapphire/Origin Live Illustrious MK3
SOTA Sapphire/SME IV.Vi
SOTA Sapphire/SME V

Thanks.
Joe
jlsmith
Thanks. Resale is not a consideration. I've had the SOTA Comet that I'm using now for 15 years. When I get something, I keep it.
I've got a 20 year old Star Sapphire vacuum table that I love. You can't go wrong with a Sota. They're built like tanks and the imaging on the vacuum tables is terrific.
I've owned three Sota's over the years and if you're gonna do it, get a Star. The vacuum hold down is definitely worth the extra few bucks.

I've also owned the SME V and SME IV.Vi, one each mounted on different Sota Stars and one on a Nottingham Mentor. Sonically, I liked the IV.Vi better than the V but if you're spending enough money for either of the SME's, go with a Tri-Planar instead.

With both SME's, I was always bothered by tracing error; Graham's too. They're a bit plump from the lower midrange on down though certainly warm and forgiving. They lack overall transparency and don't resolve recordings nearly as well as the Tri-Planar.

SME's leave much to be desired when it comes to set-up and adjustments, especially considering their retail price. VTA is a pain in the ass, not precisely repeatable and not to be done on the fly. Azimuth, forget it, not available.

Tri-Planar on the other hand is sonically much more transparent and resolving and I no longer hear tracing distortion. VTA can be done on the fly, VTF is so much more precise and easier to set and dialing in azimuth is a piece of cake.

Plenty has been written on SME vs Tri-Planar and most of what I've read confirms what I'm saying. Of course there are those who will recommend a Graham Phantom but you'll spend quite a bit more, even used, and not get better than the Tri-Planar(different maybe). Then there's the Basis Vector, a good arm sonically but we're back to a pain in the ass to set up and tweek. I know, one of my good bud's has one and he can keep it.

Happy hunting!
I am supremely happy with my SOTA Nova vacuum turntable with Origin Live Encounter Mk. III tonearm. SOTA sells a lot of this combination according to the owners, and I can see why. It's a fantastic combination!
I've been leary of a vacuum table. Clearly you all like them. How loud is the SOTA vacuum? How far away from the listener would it have to be to be totally inaudible? I have a very quiet listening room.