Some tables have soul and some not


Why is that? Do you think it is always very subjective?
Say, Nottingham Spacedeck does have it and SME does not even if in some respects SME can be called a better or depending on model much better table.
Thoughts, opinions, name callings ?
inna
The thing is getting really annoying

http://www.monoandstereo.com/2012/01/interview-with-simon-yorke.html

I know, I like and respect him so far, but if he continue like this (about DD) he is going to miss much more than a few fans.
Q: I know you strive for complete solutions, but have you ever thought about direct drive?

A: Yes, and after thinking about it I moved on. Bad idea, connecting your (microphonic) record directly to the shaft of a vibrating motor, no?
I, too, like and respect Simon Yorke but rather disappointed about the above. Another bewildering thing is his answer to the below:
Q: XLR vs RCA? Is balanced phono output a better one?

A: "XLR is a three-pin, centre-balanced transmission system. I’ve never encountered a cartridge with 3 pins per channel, have you? So, what are you going to do with that third pin on your chunky XLR plug? Taking a ‘balanced’ approach to a phono input is a good thing, but adopting the professional line-level transmission protocol (XLR) to do it is, in my opinion, mostly just playing games... marketing."


_______
Balanced isn't only 3-pin. It could also be 5-pin stereo-balanced.
If the phonostage is fully balanced(recall Violectrik), you can rewire tonearm for 5-pin stereo-balanced transmission. So aside from marketing, our cartridges/arms are balanced by default having +&- pins for each channel + Ground.
"Both BMW and Lexus are good engineering, but the former usually has soul and the latter has not. Mercedes is somewhere in between. "

Then the answer is obvious. If it's extremely reliable, it does not have soul. If it breaks a lot, it has plenty of soul. My old MG Midget, was one soulful machine.
I've read recent newz on Z-NN that any turntable that playz FZ muzik eventually get it.